15 November 2018   Gaza's balance of terror - By: Daoud Kuttab

9 November 2018   America Must Not Live And Die By The Gun - By: Alon Ben-Meir

8 November 2018   What do the midterms mean for the region? - By: Daoud Kuttab

5 November 2018   Why Is Israel Afraid of Khalida Jarrar? - By: Ramzy Baroud


1 November 2018   Turkey and Jordan: An alliance that needs attention - By: Daoud Kuttab



24 October 2018   Will the Arab League open to civil society? - By: Daoud Kuttab


18 October 2018   Best way to respond to the disappearance of Khashoggi - By: Daoud Kuttab

16 October 2018   Should the US Stop Enabling Israel? - By: Alon Ben-Meir















5 أيلول 2015   "من الأزل".. آخر كتب الراحل جونتر جراس - بقلم: المركز الألماني للإعلام (ألمانيا إنفو/ almania info)

17 May 2018

Blaming the victim

By: Daoud Kuttab
print     send by email

It is hard to believe that anyone can simply put the blame on the Palestinian side for the mass killings of unarmed protesters by Israeli snipers. How is it the Palestinian fault for being shot. There is no report of a single Israeli soldier or civilian being hurt, yet the Israeli, and even American officials, repeat the very same argument. This reminds us of what Israeli prime minister Golda Meir once said, that she will never “forgive them [the Palestinians] for having forced us to kill their sons”.
 
The US and Israeli talking points are identical. This is a Hamas-provoked violence and that Israel acted in self-defence.
 
Let us break this down.
 
Hamas is not directly involved, although it can surely end the unarmed protests if it wanted, but then it will be called a regime that does not respect the right of people to protest. Also, there are no Hamas flags anywhere at the protests. Would not Hamas want to take credit for this if it owned the protests? One of the leading members of the higher national committee for the Great March of Return, Ahmad Abu Ratima, who is not a member of Hamas, wrote an opinion article in The New York Times titled “I helped start The Gaza protests and I do not regret it”, in which he explained the idea behind the march.
 
Another problem with the exact US/Israel narrative is that Palestinians are blamed for dying. It is the Palestinians’ fault for dying because all that Israel had done was in self-defence.
 
How are well-protected Israeli snipers, shooting unarmed protesters from hundreds of meters, is considered self-defence? If the Palestinians were violent, or if they had endangered the lives of Israelis, one would expect to see scenes of injured Israelis. How many Israeli soldiers were killed or injured? The answer is zero. How many Israeli civilians were killed or injured. Again, the answer is zero.
 
So, how is this Israeli war machine shooting at unarmed Palestinians, who have not put a single Israeli in danger, is justified. It is not. No wonder the UN Commission on Human Rights, UN peace envoy and leaders of important countries are denouncing the Israeli killings.
 
But as the famous T-shirt being sold in the allies of Jerusalem says, “Don’t worry US, Israel is behind you”.
 
This symbiotic relationship is so sickening.
 
Not only does the Israeli-US narrative is in need for debunking, but the narrative of many western media outlets is just as sickening. James Martin, a Jesuit priest and editor at large at the America Magazine — the Jesuit Review, tweeted that The New York Times talked about Palestinians dying as if they passed away due to an earthquake or a health epidemic, where the truth is Israeli soldiers “killed” them.
 
The movie about Mahatma Gandi recalls a similar killing scene, but there the reporter of The Chicago Tribune described in details the way British soldiers shot one protestor after the other without having the lives of the British in any danger. How much one wishes today for powerful American journalists who are willing and courageous enough to speak out the truth.
 
Israelis and their American backers are saying that what happened in Gaza has nothing to do with President Donald Trump administration’s decision on Jerusalem.
 
Again, this myth must be debunked.
 
When the state of Israel asked to be recognised as a member of the United Nations, they were asked how they stood on two important resolutions; the United Nations Partition Plan for Palestine (resolution 181) and the right of return resolution 194. Israeli foreign minister at the time Moshe Sharett said that Israel will respect both resolutions. They have not. They have refused to deal with Jerusalem as a corpus separatum and they have totally rejected any effort to settle the Palestinian refugees’ right of return.
 
Palestinians in Gaza, and everywhere else, are the victims of this ugly massacre. Any attempts at blaming them for being killed falls clearly under the title of blaming the victims rather than blaming the war criminals who are perpetuating the killings.

* A Palestinian columnist based in Amman, Jordan. - dkuttab@ammannet.net



Name
Email
Comment
Security Code

15 تشرين ثاني 2018   استقالة ليبرمان: مأزق لنتنياهو أم مأزق للفلسطينيين؟ - بقلم: مصطفى إبراهيم

14 تشرين ثاني 2018   إلى أين تتجه حكومة نتنياهو بعد استقالة ليبرمان؟! - بقلم: شاكر فريد حسن

14 تشرين ثاني 2018   حول "معركة اليومين" والنصر المُعلن..! - بقلم: فراس ياغي

14 تشرين ثاني 2018   صفقة القرن.. تجارة امريكية فاشلة - بقلم: نور تميم

14 تشرين ثاني 2018   هكذا رفعت المقاومة رؤوسنا..! - بقلم: خالد معالي

13 تشرين ثاني 2018   تصعيد عسكري لتمرير صفقة سياسية..! - بقلم: د. إبراهيم أبراش

13 تشرين ثاني 2018   غزة تلوي ذراع الإحتلال..! - بقلم: راسم عبيدات

13 تشرين ثاني 2018   إعلان "بلفور" أكبر جرائم هذ العصر..! - بقلم: د. سنية الحسيني

13 تشرين ثاني 2018   "الصراصير العربية" وصواريخ العدوان في غزة..! - بقلم: بكر أبوبكر

13 تشرين ثاني 2018   صفقة ترامب: احتمالات التمرير ومتطلبات الإفشال..! - بقلم: هاني المصري

13 تشرين ثاني 2018   عندما صدق اعلام الاحتلال..! - بقلم: خالد معالي

13 تشرين ثاني 2018   جولة التفوق..! - بقلم: عاهد عوني فروانة

13 تشرين ثاني 2018   سيناريوهات غزة ومستقبل "الضفة"..! - بقلم: د. أحمد جميل عزم

13 تشرين ثاني 2018   عملية إسرائيلية فاشلة..! - بقلم: عمر حلمي الغول







8 حزيران 2018   ..هكذا خسر قطاع غزة أكثر من 40% من مساحته..! - بقلم: وسام زغبر







27 اّذار 2011   عداد الدفع المسبق خال من المشاعر الإنسانية..!! - بقلم: محمد أبو علان

13 شباط 2011   سقط مبارك فعادت لنا الحياة - بقلم: خالد الشرقاوي

4 شباط 2011   لا مستحيل..!! - بقلم: جودت راشد الشويكي


10 تشرين ثاني 2018   لا تفتح البابَ للذئب..! - بقلم: د. المتوكل طه

5 تشرين ثاني 2018   في انفلات الاستبداد على رقاب العباد..! - بقلم: حسن العاصي

19 تشرين أول 2018   كريستينا ياسر كريستينا..! - بقلم: د. أحمد جميل عزم


12 أيلول 2018   الثقافة بين التعهير والتطهير..! - بقلم: فراس حج محمد


8 كانون ثاني 2011   "صحافة المواطن" نافذة للأشخاص ذوي الاعاقة - بقلم: صدقي موسى

10 تشرين ثاني 2010   رساله .. - بقلم: جودت راشد الشويكي

3 تشرين ثاني 2010   شخبطة صحفية - بقلم: حسناء الرنتيسي

27 تشرين أول 2010   المدلل .. - بقلم: جودت راشد الشويكي

21 تشرين أول 2010   فضفضة مواطنية - بقلم: حسناء الرنتيسي


4 اّذار 2012   الطقش


26 كانون ثاني 2012   امرأة في الجفتلك



 
 
 
top

English | الصفحة الرئيسية | كاريكاتير | صحف ومجلات | أخبار وتقارير | اّراء حرة | الإرشيف | صوتيات | صحفيون وكتاب | راسلنا

جميع الحقوق محفوظة © لشبكة  أمين الأعلامية 2018- 1996 
تصميم وتطوير شبكة أمين الأعلامية